Proper Pepper Small Batch Pimento Cheese Classic


This product is currently sold out.

Please fill in the form below if you'd like to be notified when it becomes available.

Proper Pepper’s Classic flavor embodies the word classic - pure, genuine, rich, creamy and something that will never go out of style, just like my Frye boots, KitchenAid mixer and sterling flatware.

Whether it’s spread on a hearty cracker and topped with our raspberry pepper preserves, stuffed into a sticky date and topped with an almond or just enjoyed straight out of the tub with a spoon, this creamy and delicious cheese will be sure to please.

Flagship ingredients include white sharp Cabot cheese that has been naturally aged and of course, the official binding agent, none other than another classic, Duke’s mayonnaise.  

Choosing our classic means choosing a winner. This product tied for 3rd place in the 2019 national cheese competition sponsored by the American Cheese Society.